The broader Phoenix housing market may be stagnating, but condominium owners aren’t getting off nearly as easily.
The Valley’s median condo price has fallen to about $305,000, putting it around levels last seen in mid-2021, according to Cromford Report senior housing analyst Tina Tamboer.
That means some condo owners aren’t simply facing years without appreciation.
Depending on when they purchased, some may now have to sell for less than they paid.
“That’s a full five years of not just no appreciation,” Tamboer said, adding that the market could produce some short sales or require owners to absorb losses.
Her succinct assessment of current conditions: “The condo market is just really frigid right now.”
Tamboer said condominiums often are among the first housing types to show significant weakness during a buyer’s market, particularly when falling or stagnant single-family prices put detached homes within reach of buyers who otherwise might have considered a condo.
But price competition is only one of the problems facing the Valley’s condo market.
Tamboer cited aging properties and deferred maintenance as major concerns, along with increased lender scrutiny of the financial condition of homeowner associations.
“Aging stock is my number one,” she said. “We got a lot of older complexes that now need roofs and stucco, and they’ve got a lot of delayed maintenance.”
She also cited lending regulations as a major factor.
Those problems can reinforce each other.
Older developments eventually need expensive roof, stucco and other repairs.
Associations that have not accumulated enough reserves to pay for them may have to levy assessments against individual owners.
That can pose particular problems for retirees and other owners on fixed incomes, Tamboer said.
If an owner can’t afford the assessment, selling may become the only realistic alternative – adding another unit to a market where buyers already have considerable leverage.
At the same time, lenders increasingly examine both the physical condition of condominium developments and the financial health of their associations before approving mortgages, she said.
That means a prospective buyer who likes a particular condo may still have trouble financing it if the development itself fails to meet a lender’s requirements.
Tamboer urged agents with condo listings to contact lenders and determine whether loans have recently been approved in the development rather than assuming buyers will be able to obtain conventional financing.
“Talk to a lender and find out if they’ve done a loan in there,” she said, “or check out the complex to see if a loan has been done at all in there in the last, say, month or two.”
That, she said, can indicate whether the development is currently considered warrantable for financing.
The problems aren’t uniform across the Valley.
Tamboer said newer developments, properties close to employment centers and those with convenient freeway access generally fare better.
Newer communities also are less likely to face the combination of deferred maintenance and financing difficulties confronting some older condo complexes.
Scottsdale appeared comparatively healthy in the data she presented, although Tamboer cautioned that its numbers are affected by new townhouse construction.
New units can remain listed as under contract for extended periods while construction is completed, making demand appear stronger than it otherwise might be.
Other communities showed much weaker conditions.
Tamboer pointed to Surprise, with 33 active condo listings and only three under contract, while Rio Verde had 10 active and none under contract at the time of the presentation.
Some Pinal County markets similarly showed active condo listings without any pending contracts.
Yet, Sun City West presented almost the opposite picture, with 32 active listings and 17 under contract.
“Retirees love condos,” Tamboer said.
The disparities illustrate why Tamboer cautions against treating the Valley condo market as monolithic.
Location, age, condition and an association’s financial health increasingly matter. But the overall price trajectory is unmistakably weaker than that of detached homes.
Tamboer said the condo market has been experiencing the effects of roughly two years of buyer-market conditions and warned sellers to be realistic about both pricing and the additional financing hurdles prospective purchasers may encounter.
For buyers who can obtain financing, however, the same conditions could produce substantial negotiating opportunities, particularly as the year progresses.
Tamboer said she expects some condo sellers to become increasingly aggressive in negotiations late in the year.
For owners, that’s the other side of a market in which prices have already retreated to levels last seen about five years ago.